Considering the quality, quantity, and diversity of LGBTQ characters in films distributed under A24 and its labels in 2023, GLAAD has rated A24 with an INSUFFICIENT grade.
While A24 broke boundaries in LGBTQ representation in 2022 with films including Bodies Bodies Bodies, Everything Everywhere All At Once, and The Inspection, its 2023 films do not reach the high bar set last year. Though there is queer inclusion in genre films such as Talk to Me and Medusa Deluxe as well as queer leads in polarizing comedy Dicks: The Musical, these films alone did not live up to the high standard A24 has set for itself for excellence in LGBTQ representation.
HISTORY
In 2013, arthouse film executives Daniel Katz, David Fenkel, and John Hodges launched A24 Films. The studio began distributing films the following year and entered in co-distribution deals with DirecTV Cinema and Amazon Prime. After abbreviating the studio’s name in 2016, A24 announced a multi-year non-exclusive partnership with Apple. In 2017, A24 entered into a premium cable television broadcast deal with Showtime networks, covering all film releases through November 2022. In April of that year, the company released its membership “AAA24” for subscription, offering full access to the A24 app. During the 2023 Hollywood labor disputes, which took place from May 2 to November 9, A24 was approved to continue filming and promotional activities as the studio does not have ties to the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers. A24’s previous LGBTQ-inclusive films include GLAAD Media Award winners Moonlight (2016) and The Inspection (2022), GLAAD Media Award nominees Lady Bird (2017), Bodies Bodies Bodies (2022), and Everything Everywhere All at Once (2022), and more.
Close
Widest Theatrical Release: 233 Theaters
Vito Russo Test: FAIL
Close, a tragedy surrounding childhood best friends Leo and Remi, does not include any explicit LGBTQ content. However, when the boys start school, they are relentlessly bullied for their friendship, and their closeness leads to bullies calling them homophobic slurs. Leo pulls away from Remi because of this, and Remi ends up dying by suicide. The harrowing film shows just how dangerous bullying and hatred can be toward children when there is even the slightest deviation from the norms of masculinity.
Dicks: The Musical
Widest Theatrical Release: 635 Theaters
Vito Russo Test: PASS
This highly irreverent musical comedy from out comedians Josh Sharp and Aaron Jackson stars the pair as identical twins (who look nothing alike). From the beginning voiceover of the film, which states “the following film was bravely written by two homosexuals, the first time gay men have ever written anything,” it is clear that the comedy is meant to be tongue-in-cheek. The first part of the film insists that the lead brothers, Craig and Trevor, are both heterosexual as they go about their lives of debauchery. When they discover that they are twins, they try to get their parents back together, a la The Parent Trap. However, they run into some roadblocks given that their father, Harris, comes out as gay to Trevor in song. Still, Harris does have interest in his former lover, Evelyn, when he sees her again, saying he may be attracted to both men and women. Evelyn reacts with shock that anyone could possibly be attracted to both men and women, a clear dig at bisexual erasure. Toward the end of the film, Trevor and Craig have a massive falling out. When the brothers make up, their reunion turns into the two of them having explicit sex. The film ends with the two twin brothers getting married as God himself officiates their wedding. God announces that he too is both straight and gay, and the film ends with a singalong that proclaims “God is a f– and all love is love.”
This movie is one that clearly does not take itself seriously, and delights at poking fun at the concepts of heterosexuality and masculinity. Though it does veer into offensive territory, particularly in its portrayal of incest, it is hard to imagine a world where any audience takes this film at face value.
Medusa Deluxe
Widest Theatrical Release: 7 Theaters
Vito Russo Test: PASS
This British film is set at a hairdressing contest where one of the contestants has been mysteriously murdered and scalped. The victim is Mosca, a hairdresser, who was gay. The film introduces us to further queer characters as the plot unfolds, including Angel, Mosca’s long term partner; Rene, who runs the competition and was previously involved with Mosca; and Gac, a security guard who also had a brief fling with Mosca. All of these characters are deeply flawed, as are the straight characters in the film. As the plot is revealed, it becomes apparent that Mosca died of a drug overdose, and that Gac scalped him out of devotion. Though violent, the film itself was a character driven take on the murder mystery genre, with an ensemble of queer characters who were nonviolent, survived the film, and were simply flawed individuals.
Talk to Me
Widest Theatrical Release: 2,379 Theaters
Vito Russo Test: PASS
This horror film follows a group of friends who have found an embalmed hand that leads them to communicate with spirits. One of the friends, Hayley, hosts the party that introduces the group to the hand. Hayley’s gender is never a topic of conversation, but they are referred to with they/them pronouns throughout the run of the film. Including a nonbinary character in a group of young friends makes sense for this film, as younger generations are identifying more and more outside the gender binary.
Though the pronoun usage is the only onscreen reference to Hayley’s gender identity, the casting of trans actor Zoe Terakes in this role led to Kuwait banning the film. It is disheartening that something as simple as an actor’s gender and they/them pronouns can lead to such censorship.
When You Finish Saving the World
Widest Theatrical Release: 403 Theaters
Vito Russo Test: FAIL
This film did not contain any LGBTQ characters or content, which is especially disappointing given that the lead character, Ziggy, was bisexual in the Audible original that the film was based on. There is a brief mention of Ziggy having a crush on a girl in the movie, yet no other mention of his sexuality. It would have been easy to add an additional line to confirm his sexuality, even if it is not a large part of the narrative, and this film could have had a bisexual lead.
You Hurt My Feelings
Widest Theatrical Release: 912 Theaters
Vito Russo Test: FAIL
You Hurt My Feelings follows couple Beth and Don, a writer and therapist respectively, who have a falling out when Beth finds out that Don did not like her most recent book. There is brief queer representation in this film, when Beth meets a lesbian couple at a bar and asks what they would do if they were in her situation. Don also has a client who mentions his male partner in passing. None of these characters have a significant bearing on the plot, though it is a positive to see queer people existing in the world.
OPPORTUNITIES AHEAD
There are a number of upcoming A24 films that feature LGBTQ characters and storylines and several that have already been released in 2024. I Saw the TV Glow, from transfeminine and nonbinary writer and director Jane Schoenbrun, features a prominent lesbian character, Maddy, and features a number of LGBTQ actors, such as Justice Smith, Brigette Lundy-Payne, Phoebe Bridgers, and Lindsey Jordan. Problemista, an absurdist comedy written by and starring gay comedian Julio Torres, features a large cast of LGBTQ actors such as James Scully, Spike Einbinder, Larry Owens, Kelly McCormack, and Megan Stalter. The film features a gay main character, Alejandro, as well as a number of other LGBTQ characters throughout. The romantic thriller Love Lies Bleeding also features a lesbian relationship between bisexual gym manager Lou and body-builder Jackie, played by LGBTQ actors Kristen Stewart and Katy O’Brian.
Mother Mary, an upcoming music film starring Anne Hathaway and Michaela Coel, will follow a musician and her relationship with a fashion designer. The upcoming Parthenope features Gary Oldman as John Cheever, a bisexual author. Finally, the film Y2K features trans actor Lachlan Watson, and the film Tuesday features queer and nonbinary actor Lola Petticrew; it is very possible that the identities of the actors may transfer to the characters they portray on screen.
Your gift allows us to track the impact of our work, helping us better understand the state of acceptance and address the gaps with advocacy — like pushing for more trans representation in movies.
Chanukah, Christmas, Eid al-Adha, Kwanzaa, New Year's, Muharram, the Lunar New Year and other seasonal celebrations will soon set the stage for countless news and feature stories in mainstream and ethnic print and electronic media.
The film is a moving account of a family with two moms, a son and a daughter. When the children make contact with their donor, the dynamics of the family are challenged.